FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

I Am Legend

2007 4/51 review

Original review

4/5

There is something incredibly fascinating about the idea of being almost completely alone in a world that used to be filled with millions of people.

And I Am Legend brings that idea to life remarkably well.

I genuinely enjoyed this movie.

The atmosphere is fantastic, the premise is compelling, and Will Smith delivers a performance that makes the entire experience much more interesting than a conventional postapocalyptic action film.

What I particularly love is the setting.

New York City is one of the most recognizable and densely populated places in the world.

It represents movement, noise, traffic, enormous crowds, and the constant presence of other human beings.

And suddenly, all of that is gone.

The streets are empty.

Nature is gradually reclaiming the buildings.

Abandoned cars have become part of the landscape.

And one man is trying to maintain something resembling a normal life in a city that has completely lost its purpose.

That contrast is extraordinary.

There is something almost beautiful about the silence.

But the longer you think about it, the more terrifying it becomes.

Because this is not a peaceful world.

It is a world where almost everything that once made human civilization meaningful has disappeared.

And Robert Neville is left trying to survive among its remains.

Will Smith is excellent in the role.

What makes his performance so effective is the way he communicates loneliness without constantly having to explain it.

Neville talks to mannequins, maintains routines, carries out experiments, and desperately tries to preserve some sense of normality.

Those details are both charming and heartbreaking.

You understand that these routines are not simply habits.

They are part of what keeps him going.

And that makes his relationship with Sam so important.

She is not merely a dog accompanying him on his adventures.

She represents companionship, loyalty, and the last remaining piece of an emotional world that has otherwise disappeared.

Their relationship gives the story warmth in an environment where warmth has become incredibly rare.

And it makes the moments when Neville's carefully constructed existence begins to fall apart considerably more painful.

I also really appreciate how the movie combines different genres.

At times, it feels like a survival drama.

At others, a psychological study of extreme isolation.

And then suddenly, it becomes a genuinely frightening horror film.

The infected create a constant sense of danger, but what makes them particularly effective is how the film builds anticipation around their presence.

During the day, Neville can explore the city.

He can search for supplies.

He can continue his experiments.

But as darkness approaches, the atmosphere changes completely.

Suddenly, the same streets that seemed strangely peaceful become terrifying.

That contrast creates fantastic suspense.

And the film understands how to use it.

The story is also genuinely exciting.

Neville's search for a cure gives his isolation a purpose beyond simply surviving another day.

He is not just waiting for something to happen.

He is trying to change the situation.

Trying to understand what went wrong.

And perhaps trying to give humanity another chance.

That gives the movie a direction that makes the experience consistently engaging.

Unfortunately, I have one major problem with the film.

The ending.

And it is a particularly frustrating problem because I enjoyed almost everything leading up to it.

I simply do not find Neville's sacrifice convincing.

The story presents his death as a necessary final act, but I never felt that he had exhausted every possibility of surviving.

To me, the situation does not convincingly establish that dying is his only remaining option.

And that makes the ending feel unnecessarily tragic.

I do not have a problem with a protagonist dying if the story earns that conclusion.

Some of my favorite films contain incredibly sad endings.

But the death needs to feel meaningful, inevitable, or at least believable within the circumstances established by the movie.

Here, I kept thinking that Neville could have made it out alive.

And when you are supposed to be emotionally overwhelmed by a character's sacrifice, questioning whether that sacrifice was even necessary is not exactly the reaction the filmmakers should be hoping for.

That is why I find the alternative ending so interesting.

Not simply because Neville survives, although I certainly prefer that outcome.

But because it introduces a different perspective on the infected and the relationship between them and humanity.

It suggests that the creatures might possess more awareness, social connection, and recognizable motivations than Neville initially understands.

And suddenly, the story becomes considerably more philosophically interesting.

Who is actually the monster?

How does Neville appear from the perspective of the beings he has been capturing and experimenting on?

And what happens when the person who believes he is saving humanity begins to realize that the world may no longer belong exclusively to humans?

Those are fascinating questions.

And I think the alternative ending offers a much more interesting foundation for the story than an unnecessary heroic sacrifice.

That is also why I am genuinely excited about the planned sequel.

The idea of continuing the story from that alternative ending opens up possibilities that would not exist if the original theatrical conclusion remained definitive.

I would love to see how the world has developed, how the infected have changed, and what kind of place humanity now occupies within that new reality.

Unfortunately, I have already been waiting far too long for the movie to arrive.

And the lack of concrete progress has become rather frustrating.

Still, none of that changes how much I enjoyed the original.

I Am Legend has an outstanding premise, a fantastic atmosphere, strong suspense, and a central performance that makes the loneliness of its world feel genuinely affecting.

It is one of those science fiction films where the setting alone is interesting enough to make me want to explore it for hours.

And even though the ending prevents it from becoming one of my absolute favorites, the journey itself is easily worth four stars.

An atmospheric, exciting, and surprisingly emotional survival thriller with an excellent Will Smith performance and a fascinating postapocalyptic world.

Four stars.

But I am absolutely counting the alternative ending as my preferred conclusion.

Robert Neville deserved a better way out.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗