Original review
There's Something About Mary is one of those comedies where I completely understand what makes people enjoy it.
I just happen to be one of the people who do not enjoy that particular kind of humor very much.
And that is probably the simplest explanation for my rating.
The film is funny.
There are genuinely entertaining moments, and I can certainly appreciate the willingness to embrace completely ridiculous situations.
But everything is so exaggerated, awkward, and deliberately outrageous that the comedy often becomes more exhausting than enjoyable for me.
The premise itself is perfectly suitable for a romantic comedy.
Ted is a relatively ordinary man who cannot seem to forget the girl he fell in love with years earlier.
The problem is that almost everything surrounding his attempts to reconnect with Mary becomes increasingly absurd.
And the movie is absolutely committed to making those situations as uncomfortable and ridiculous as possible.
That is its entire comedic identity.
I can respect that commitment.
There is something impressive about a film that knows exactly what kind of humor it wants to deliver and refuses to become more conventional simply to appeal to a broader audience.
But understanding a joke and actually enjoying it are two different things.
The film constantly relies on embarrassing situations, exaggerated behavior, misunderstandings, and characters who seem almost incapable of responding to anything in a normal way.
Sometimes that works.
The absurdity becomes funny precisely because it is so unexpected.
But at other times, I simply find myself wondering how much more ridiculous the situation is going to become before the movie finally moves on.
And that is not necessarily the feeling I want from a comedy.
Ben Stiller is a good choice for this kind of role.
He has a particular talent for portraying characters who find themselves in situations that become progressively more uncomfortable.
His reactions often make the embarrassment even more entertaining.
Cameron Diaz also brings a great deal of charm to the film.
And the surrounding characters contribute to the almost cartoonish world the movie creates.
The performances are not really my problem.
It is more the entire approach to comedy.
I tend to enjoy humor that develops naturally through characters, dialogue, or situations that are funny because of how believable their absurdity feels.
There's Something About Mary often takes the opposite approach.
It starts with an uncomfortable idea and pushes it as far as possible.
Then it pushes a little further.
And sometimes even further than that.
For many viewers, that is exactly what makes the film hilarious.
For me, it eventually becomes too much.
I also think that the romantic element gets overshadowed by the comedy.
The characters are constantly being placed in absurd situations, and so much of the entertainment depends on those situations escalating that the actual relationship at the center never became especially meaningful to me.
And that limits how much I can connect with the film beyond its jokes.
A romantic comedy does not necessarily need to be profound.
I am perfectly capable of enjoying something lighthearted and silly.
But I usually appreciate a certain warmth or emotional authenticity underneath the humor.
Something that makes the characters feel like people rather than simply vehicles for another ridiculous scene.
Here, that connection never became particularly strong.
Instead, I mostly experienced a series of increasingly exaggerated comedic situations surrounding a romance that did not interest me enough to compensate.
I can absolutely see why the film became such a recognizable comedy classic.
It has a distinctive identity, memorable scenes, and the confidence to embrace a style of humor that many other movies would probably consider too outrageous.
And I appreciate that it is not trying to be something else.
But personal taste matters.
Especially in comedy.
A joke that makes one person laugh uncontrollably can leave another person completely unmoved.
And a style of humor that feels wonderfully absurd to some people can simply become a little too much for others.
That is exactly how I feel about this movie.
Two stars.
An occasionally funny, charmingly ridiculous, and completely over the top romantic comedy that clearly knows its audience.
Unfortunately, I am just not really part of that audience.
I can appreciate the jokes.
I simply do not want quite so many of them to be this absurd.