FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

Eternals

2021 1.5/51 review

Original review

1.5/5

Eternals is one of those films that feels like it is trying to do absolutely everything at once — introduce a huge cast, build emotional depth, explore cosmic mythology, feel important, feel modern, feel different from the rest of the MCU — and in the end, almost none of it really works. Instead of feeling ambitious in a satisfying way, it just feels overloaded, unfocused, and strangely hollow.

My biggest issue with the film is that it tries so hard to make every character feel significant, but never gives most of them enough time, chemistry, or writing to actually make that happen. The result is a cast full of people who should feel epic and memorable, yet somehow come across as flat, distant, or just weirdly underdeveloped. The movie wants you to care deeply about all of them, but it never earns that investment. It is not that a large ensemble can’t work — plenty of films prove that it can — but here it feels like the story is spread so thin that nobody gets enough space to truly land.

And then there is the dialogue, which for me was genuinely painful at times. So many conversations feel awkward, forced, and weirdly unnatural, to the point where some scenes become hard to sit through. Not in a funny camp way, not in a charmingly cheesy Marvel way — just plain uncomfortable. It is the kind of writing that makes you physically feel the second-hand embarrassment. Instead of helping the characters feel more human, it often does the exact opposite and makes everything feel even more artificial.

What makes it even more frustrating is that the film clearly wants to be seen as something bigger and more elevated than the usual Marvel formula, but in trying so hard to separate itself, it loses a lot of what actually made Marvel films enjoyable in the first place. The charm, the rhythm, the entertaining character dynamics, the sense of fun — so much of that is missing here. It barely feels connected to what made the MCU work at its best. Different is not automatically better, and in this case, “different” mostly just ended up feeling lifeless.

For me, Eternals also marks the point where the decline of Marvel became impossible to ignore. You can debate which movie started the weaker era, but this is the one that really felt like a warning sign. Even though there have definitely been a few better Marvel films again since then, the contrast to the earlier MCU movies is still huge. The films before Eternals were, in my opinion, miles better in terms of tone, writing, entertainment value, and basic audience connection.

That is probably the most disappointing part: this is not a film that fails because it lacked money, scale, or ambition. It fails because it mistakes heaviness for depth, awkward seriousness for maturity, and a giant ensemble for emotional richness. Underneath all the spectacle, there just is not much that actually grabs you.

1.5 stars because the ambition is visible. Everything else left me cold.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗