Original review
What makes Iron Lung so impressive to me is that it works incredibly well as a film without constantly needing the “for an indie production” disclaimer attached to it. Yes, the fact that this was made on a much smaller scale makes it even more admirable, but even outside of that context, it is still a genuinely well-made and effective movie. The production quality is strong, the atmosphere is intense, and it understands exactly how to make a confined setting feel oppressive in the best possible way.
The strongest part of the film for me was easily the tension. Being trapped in that submarine-like capsule creates such a suffocating, claustrophobic feeling that the movie almost becomes physically uncomfortable at times. And I mean that as a compliment. It really sells the idea of being stuck in something small, isolated, and hostile, with no real sense of safety or escape. That pressure is what carries a lot of the film, and it does so very well.
At the same time, that same quality is also part of why the film didn’t go even higher for me. The atmosphere is so heavy and so oppressive that it also becomes a bit overwhelming in a way that started to limit my enjoyment. That kind of suffocating tension is effective, but I personally would have liked a little more balance through stronger story development or more insight into the background of what is actually going on. The film is very good at making you feel trapped, but not always as good at making you feel fully grounded in the larger narrative.
That is where my biggest issue comes in: I found the story too confusing. Not necessarily in an intriguing “I need to think about this more” way, but more in a way that left me with more questions than answers by the end. And usually I do not mind ambiguity when it feels intentional and thematically rewarding, but here it felt like I was still missing key pieces rather than being invited to interpret them. I wanted more context, more history, and more of a clearer foundation for what I was supposed to take away from everything.
What makes that especially interesting is that even revisiting the game afterward did not really solve that problem for me. If anything, it confirmed that the story itself is built in a way that keeps a lot of things just out of reach. That mystery is obviously part of the appeal for some people, but for me it also created a certain emotional distance. I was engaged by the tension and impressed by the execution, but not completely pulled in by the narrative itself.
Still, I have a lot of respect for what Mark Fischbach achieved here. This is a very well-produced film that shows a huge amount of control, creativity, and ambition. It may not be fully on the level of the very best Hollywood productions, but that honestly makes it more impressive in some ways, not less. It feels like proof of what is possible when a singular vision is executed with enough care and commitment. Even if it does not beat the strongest major studio productions, it absolutely earns respect as a serious competitor and as a reminder that one person with a clear vision can create something genuinely memorable.
So while I do wish the story had given me more and left me less confused by the end, I still think Iron Lung is a very strong film: tense, atmospheric, impressively produced, and far more than just a novelty project.
A suffocating, well-crafted thriller that impressed me more with its execution than with its storytelling.