FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

Zodiac

2007 2.5/51 review

Original review

2.5/5

Zodiac is a fascinating story trapped inside a movie that takes considerably too long to tell it.

And that is frustrating because there is so much here that should work incredibly well for me.

David Fincher.

Jake Gyllenhaal.

A disturbing true crime case.

An investigation that gradually becomes an obsession.

And the kind of psychological uncertainty that can make a crime thriller incredibly compelling.

On paper, those ingredients sound fantastic.

And to be fair, the story itself genuinely is interesting.

The Zodiac murders remain one of the most unsettling chapters in American criminal history, not simply because of the violence, but because of the mystery surrounding the person responsible.

The letters.

The codes.

The threats.

The constant uncertainty about what information can be trusted.

And the terrifying possibility that someone responsible for such horrific crimes could remain unidentified despite enormous investigative efforts.

That is an incredibly strong foundation for a film.

What I especially appreciate is that Zodiac is not simply interested in showing the crimes.

It focuses on the people attempting to understand them.

The investigators, journalists, and everyone gradually becoming involved in a mystery that seems increasingly resistant to a definitive solution.

That is where the psychological side becomes fascinating.

An investigation like this does not simply consume time.

It can consume the people involved.

The longer the mystery remains unresolved, the more difficult it becomes to accept that some questions may never receive satisfying answers.

And that obsession is probably one of the most interesting aspects of the entire story.

Jake Gyllenhaal is also an excellent choice for this kind of film.

He is one of my favorite actors, and I particularly appreciate his ability to portray characters whose determination gradually becomes something much more psychologically complicated.

There is a certain vulnerability to his performances that works beautifully in stories about obsession, uncertainty, and the desire to understand something that may ultimately be impossible to understand completely.

And Zodiac gives him material that fits those strengths.

The problem is that the film's pacing gradually undermined much of my enthusiasm.

It is simply too drawn out.

I understand that the investigation itself took years and that the enormous amount of uncertainty is fundamental to the story.

A film about an unresolved criminal investigation should not necessarily move like a conventional action thriller.

But there is still a difference between accurately portraying the exhausting nature of an investigation and making the viewing experience unnecessarily exhausting.

For me, Zodiac regularly crosses that line.

There are stretches where the narrative loses too much momentum.

New information appears.

Another possibility is explored.

Another lead emerges.

Another uncertainty remains.

And while that repetition makes sense given the nature of the case, it eventually becomes less engaging as a cinematic experience.

I found myself appreciating the story more than I was actually enjoying the film.

That is never an ideal situation.

The ending is another interesting aspect.

Obviously, a film based on a case without a conclusive identification of the killer cannot simply manufacture a satisfying resolution without departing from the historical reality.

And I respect that.

There is something unsettling about an ending that refuses to provide the certainty audiences have come to expect from crime thrillers.

Real investigations do not always conclude with the detective identifying the murderer and everyone finally understanding what happened.

Sometimes uncertainty remains.

Sometimes the evidence is incomplete.

And sometimes the people searching for answers never receive the closure they desperately wanted.

That is an important reality.

But understanding why the film ends this way does not necessarily make the experience more satisfying.

After such an extended investigation, the lack of definitive resolution leaves you with a strange combination of intellectual fascination and emotional frustration.

And that is essentially how I feel about Zodiac as a whole.

I appreciate the historical subject.

I appreciate the performances.

I appreciate the psychological questions surrounding obsession and uncertainty.

But the film never convinced me that its long runtime was necessary to communicate those ideas as effectively as possible.

There is a much tighter version of this story that I suspect I would have enjoyed considerably more.

Two and a half stars.

A genuinely fascinating true crime story with strong performances and an unsettling atmosphere, unfortunately held back by pacing that makes the investigation feel almost as exhausting for the audience as it was for the people involved.

An interesting mystery.

A frustratingly lengthy movie.

And a conclusion that reminds you that real life rarely cares about giving an audience a satisfying ending.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗