FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

Wonka

2023 4/51 review

Original review

4/5

I went into Wonka with one major problem already working against it:

For me, Johnny Depp’s Willy Wonka is almost impossible to beat.

That interpretation of the character is so deeply ingrained in my mind that almost anyone stepping into the role is going to have a difficult time competing with it.

And yet, Wonka still managed to win me over.

The film has an incredible amount of charm. The world is colorful, playful, and appropriately strange, and the entire thing has that slightly magical quality a Willy Wonka story absolutely needs.

The performances are strong, the music works really well, and the central concept of exploring a younger Wonka gives the movie enough independence that it does not feel like it is simply trying to recreate something that already existed.

That was probably the smartest choice.

Instead of constantly asking Timothée Chalamet to imitate previous versions of Willy Wonka, the film gives him the opportunity to create a younger, more optimistic version of the character.

And he does a good job with it.

The musical elements also fit the world much better than I initially expected. They help create this whimsical atmosphere and give the film a kind of classic family-movie charm that feels increasingly rare.

There is a genuine warmth to the whole production.

The story is not incredibly complex, but it does not need to be. The concept works, the movie knows exactly what tone it wants, and most importantly, it is simply enjoyable.

Still, whenever I think of Willy Wonka, Johnny Depp remains the version that immediately comes to mind for me.

Chalamet is good.

Depp is Wonka.

At least in my head.

That comparison probably keeps this from reaching an even higher rating, but 4 stars is still a strong result for a film that had a nearly impossible character comparison to overcome.

Charming, musical, beautifully designed, and far better than I expected — even if Johnny Depp’s Wonka remains untouchable for me.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗