FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

Why Him?

2016 3.5/51 review

Original review

3.5/5

Some movies become special because of their exceptional storytelling, extraordinary performances, or emotional depth.

And then there are movies that become special because they are simply part of your life.

Why Him? belongs firmly in the second category for me.

Watching this movie at home has become something of a Christmas tradition.

And honestly, I think that is a wonderful achievement for a comedy that is so completely ridiculous.

Because Why Him? is not exactly the kind of film anyone would describe as subtle.

It is loud.

It is vulgar.

It is awkward.

And it takes almost every opportunity to make its characters as uncomfortable as possible.

But somehow, that is exactly what makes it so entertaining.

The premise is wonderfully simple.

A protective father visits his daughter and discovers that her boyfriend is almost everything he would never have imagined for her.

Ned Fleming represents a relatively conventional understanding of family, responsibility, and appropriate behavior.

He has certain expectations about what a successful and respectable person should look like.

And then he meets Laird Mayhew.

A wealthy, eccentric, completely unpredictable man who seems almost incapable of behaving according to ordinary social conventions.

That contrast is the entire foundation of the comedy.

And it works surprisingly well.

Bryan Cranston is fantastic as Ned.

There is something incredibly entertaining about watching an otherwise reasonable man gradually lose his ability to deal with the situations surrounding him.

He tries to remain polite.

He tries to understand.

He tries to maintain some control over the situation.

But every new interaction seems specifically designed to test just how much absurdity one person can tolerate.

And Cranston is excellent at communicating that frustration.

His facial expressions alone can make a scene funny.

You can almost see the internal struggle between wanting to behave like a responsible adult and desperately wanting to escape the entire situation.

James Franco provides the perfect contrast.

Laird is so exaggerated that he almost seems like a character from a completely different movie.

His lifestyle is absurd.

His behavior is often inappropriate.

And his understanding of personal boundaries appears to operate according to rules that nobody else has ever heard of.

But there is also something strangely charming about him.

He is not simply trying to make Ned miserable.

He genuinely wants to be accepted.

And that gives the character a little more personality than a conventional obnoxious boyfriend.

The entire comedy depends on the tension between those two men.

One desperately wants the world to remain predictable.

The other seems almost physically incapable of making anything predictable.

And watching them attempt to understand each other is incredibly entertaining.

I also appreciate that the film embraces its own ridiculousness.

It does not constantly try to become more sophisticated than it actually is.

The jokes are often completely inappropriate.

The situations are exaggerated.

And the characters regularly behave in ways that would make absolutely no sense outside a comedy.

But the movie knows that.

And it seems to enjoy every minute of it.

There is something refreshing about that kind of confidence.

Not every comedy needs to be intelligent social satire.

Not every joke needs to reveal some profound truth about human behavior.

Sometimes watching two talented actors perform increasingly ridiculous material is entertaining enough.

And Why Him? delivers exactly that.

What makes the film particularly enjoyable for me, though, is its Christmas atmosphere.

It is not necessarily the kind of traditional holiday movie built around beautiful decorations, sentimental speeches, and a perfectly heartwarming family reunion.

Instead, it takes a familiar Christmas setting and fills it with completely dysfunctional interactions.

And somehow, that creates its own kind of holiday charm.

There is something funny about watching a family gathering become increasingly chaotic during a time of year when everyone is supposedly trying to be especially loving and peaceful.

The contrast works beautifully.

And it makes the film an entertaining alternative to the more conventional Christmas movies.

For me, that has gradually become part of its identity.

It is no longer simply a comedy I watched once and found amusing.

It is a movie I associate with being at home during Christmas.

With the familiar atmosphere of the holidays.

With knowing exactly what kind of ridiculous entertainment I am about to get.

And with enjoying that experience again year after year.

That kind of personal connection matters.

A film can become part of a tradition without necessarily being a masterpiece.

And sometimes, the movies we return to most often are not the ones we would consider the greatest cinematic achievements.

They are the ones that create a particular feeling.

The ones that become associated with a certain time of year.

The ones that feel familiar in the best possible way.

Why Him? has become one of those movies for me.

Of course, it is far from perfect.

The humor is frequently excessive, the story follows predictable patterns, and some of the jokes are clearly more interested in being outrageous than genuinely clever.

But I do not think those weaknesses prevent it from being a genuinely entertaining experience.

Its greatest strength is the chemistry between the characters and the confidence with which it embraces its own absurdity.

Bryan Cranston and James Franco make an excellent comedic combination.

The Christmas setting adds a wonderful sense of familiarity.

And the entire movie is just ridiculous enough to remain entertaining even after multiple viewings.

Three and a half stars.

A wonderfully inappropriate, chaotic, and surprisingly charming Christmas comedy with fantastic comedic chemistry and a very particular kind of holiday atmosphere.

Not exactly sophisticated cinema.

But an annual Christmas tradition that I genuinely look forward to.

And sometimes, becoming part of someone's Christmas is a greater achievement than any critical review could ever measure.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗