FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

The Shape of Water

2017 1.5/51 review

Original review

1.5/5

The Shape of Water is one of those films where I can absolutely recognize the artistic ambition behind it while simultaneously admitting that the experience itself did very little for me.

And honestly, that makes it a strangely difficult movie to rate.

Because I do not necessarily think this is a poorly made film.

Quite the opposite.

There is an enormous amount of artistic intention in almost everything happening on screen.

The cinematography is carefully composed, the atmosphere is distinctive, the production design is imaginative, and Guillermo del Toro clearly has a very specific vision of the story he wants to tell.

You can see the craftsmanship.

You can understand that there are deeper ideas underneath the surface.

But none of that automatically means the film works for me.

And unfortunately, it really did not.

The central concept is certainly unusual.

A lonely woman developing an emotional and romantic connection with a mysterious amphibious creature is not exactly the kind of story you encounter every day.

There are interesting philosophical questions hidden inside that premise.

What makes someone human?

How much of our identity is defined by our appearance?

Why do people instinctively fear or reject things they cannot understand?

And can genuine connection exist between individuals who appear to have almost nothing in common?

Those are fascinating questions.

The film also explores loneliness, exclusion, prejudice, and the desire to be understood by someone who sees beyond the limitations imposed by society.

I can appreciate that.

I can even understand why so many people find the film beautiful and deeply moving.

But for me, the entire experience felt almost too abstract.

There is a difference between a film using fantasy to explore something meaningful and a film becoming so strange that I struggle to connect with the emotions it is trying to communicate.

The Shape of Water repeatedly crossed that line for me.

The romance, the visual symbolism, and the overall tone felt increasingly bizarre rather than genuinely moving.

And at some point, I simply stopped connecting with the story.

Instead of becoming emotionally invested in the characters, I found myself watching everything unfold from a distance.

That is especially frustrating because I normally enjoy films that are willing to experiment with their storytelling.

I love directors who have a recognizable artistic identity.

I appreciate symbolism.

I enjoy psychological depth and stories that allow different interpretations.

But there still needs to be something that makes me want to enter that world.

And this particular world never really invited me in.

The atmosphere is simultaneously beautiful and deeply uncomfortable, and I often found myself unable to decide whether the film wanted me to feel wonder, sadness, romance, or disgust.

Perhaps that emotional ambiguity is part of its appeal.

For me, it mostly created distance.

By the time the film ended, I was left with a genuinely strange feeling.

Not the satisfying discomfort of a psychological thriller that has given me something fascinating to think about.

More the feeling that I had watched something undeniably artistic without ever really understanding why I was supposed to enjoy it.

And I think that distinction matters.

A film can be intellectually interesting without being emotionally successful.

It can be visually beautiful without being enjoyable.

And it can have a meaningful message while presenting that message in a way that simply does not connect with a particular viewer.

That is exactly how I feel about The Shape of Water.

I respect what Guillermo del Toro was trying to create.

I recognize the artistry and the philosophical ambition.

But the unusual romance, the abstract storytelling, and the increasingly strange atmosphere made the entire experience far more alienating than moving for me.

Maybe that is simply a matter of taste.

Some films speak to you immediately.

Others never manage to establish that connection, no matter how much artistic talent went into them.

The Shape of Water belongs firmly in the second category for me.

A visually imaginative and undeniably artistic fantasy with interesting philosophical ideas, but one whose abstraction and bizarre emotional atmosphere left me feeling more uncomfortable than captivated.

I can appreciate the art without loving the movie.

And sometimes that is simply how it goes.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗