FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

The Old Guard

2020 3.5/51 review

Original review

3.5/5

The Old Guard has a fantastic concept.

Immortal warriors who have lived through different eras of human history immediately opens the door to an almost ridiculous amount of interesting storytelling. Different centuries, different conflicts, relationships that have existed for hundreds of years, the psychological consequences of immortality, and the question of what endless life actually does to a person.

Which is exactly why I found myself wishing the movie had spent much more time on almost everything except its main story.

The cast is strong, the characters are interesting, and the basic premise immediately makes you curious about who these people actually are.

But then the film only gives you fragments.

Every glimpse into their past made me more interested than much of what was happening in the present-day storyline. When you have characters who have literally experienced centuries of history, their individual lives automatically become fascinating. Their friendships, losses, relationships, and everything they have witnessed could easily sustain entire films on their own.

And honestly, I would watch those films.

That is probably my biggest criticism of The Old Guard: its backstory is more interesting than its main story.

The central plot is entertaining enough and works perfectly well as an action movie, but it almost feels like the least imaginative thing you could do with such an imaginative premise. I kept wanting the movie to stop moving forward and instead go backwards.

Show me how these people met.

Show me what they experienced hundreds of years ago.

Show me how their relationships changed after watching generations of ordinary humans grow old and die.

Show me what immortality actually costs them.

Those are the parts that could have given this movie real emotional weight.

Instead, the film often feels like an introduction to characters whose most interesting stories happened long before the movie started.

Still, the concept is strong enough, the performances are good enough, and the overall execution is entertaining enough for 3.5 stars. There is clearly a much bigger and more fascinating world here.

I just wish the film had actually let us spend more time inside it.

A great concept with strong characters — unfortunately, I was much more interested in the centuries of stories behind them than the story happening in front of me.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗