Original review
I went into The Odyssey with fairly high expectations, and somehow Christopher Nolan managed to deliver a film that feels both enormous and surprisingly restrained.
What impressed me most is how closely the film stays connected to the original myth.
Having grown up absolutely devouring the Percy Jackson books, I already knew many of the characters, creatures, locations, and ideas surrounding Greek mythology. That made watching this even more enjoyable because so many elements immediately carried additional meaning. You recognize names, understand relationships, and notice details that might otherwise simply pass by as another part of the story.
There is something incredibly satisfying about finally seeing this world presented with this level of scale and seriousness.
And the cast is fantastic.
Matt Damon works extremely well as Odysseus because he brings both physical presence and exhaustion to the character. This is not someone beginning a grand adventure. This is a man who has already spent years at war and now just desperately wants to get home.
You can feel how much the journey has taken from him.
The supporting cast is equally impressive, and overall I think the casting choices were remarkably strong.
The one choice that visually felt slightly strange to me was Elliot Page as Sinon.
That has nothing to do with the actual acting performance. It was simply difficult for me to fully buy the physical presence of the character among a group of hardened warriors who have supposedly spent around a decade fighting at Troy. Surrounded by physically imposing soldiers of different ages, Page looked noticeably smaller and more fragile, which made the character stand out in a way I do not think was necessarily intended.
It is a relatively minor issue, but visually it caught my attention every time.
On the other hand, I absolutely loved James Remar as Tiresias.
His performance as the blind seer was one of those smaller appearances that completely captures your attention. There is something incredibly fitting about the way that sequence is performed and staged. He feels ancient, mysterious, and somehow disconnected from the ordinary world around him.
The music is another huge strength.
Ludwig Göransson does not simply create another enormous cinematic score. The percussion in particular feels completely appropriate for the world. Those drums give certain sequences a primal energy and constantly reinforce the feeling that you are watching an ancient story rather than a modern fantasy wearing Greek costumes.
The soundtrack supports the images instead of constantly trying to overpower them.
And visually, this film is beautiful.
What surprised me is how little this feels like the stereotypical Nolan movie.
There is no enormous narrative puzzle constantly demanding that you reconstruct the chronology. There is no major mindfuck waiting to completely redefine everything you have just watched. There is also surprisingly little emphasis on spectacle purely for the sake of spectacle.
Instead, Nolan seems genuinely interested in simply telling The Odyssey.
The landscapes matter.
The journey matters.
The people Odysseus meets matter.
The mythology matters.
There is a patience to the filmmaking that allows the scenery and the story to become the spectacle.
And honestly, I really appreciated that.
Nolan did not need to turn Homer into Tenet.
One of my favorite changes from the original story is surprisingly small.
Odysseus gets to acknowledge his dog before he dies.
In Homer’s story, Argos recognizes Odysseus after all those years, but Odysseus cannot openly greet him without risking revealing his identity. Argos finally sees his master return home and then dies.
It is already heartbreaking.
But allowing Odysseus that small moment of recognition in the film simply felt better for the heart.
It may not be completely faithful to the original scene, but emotionally I prefer it.
And that is an example of adaptation done well.
You can respect the source material without treating every single detail as untouchable.
I also loved that the movie has an actual ending.
That sounds ridiculous to praise, but so many modern films seem terrified of simply finishing their story. Everything needs to tease another installment, leave five questions unanswered, or create space for some future cinematic universe.
The Odyssey actually ends.
You finish the journey.
You arrive somewhere.
There is closure.
I missed that.
My main criticism is that sometimes the film is almost too focused on keeping the journey moving.
There are characters and pieces of mythology that I desperately wanted to know more about.
The imposing warriors in the silver armor immediately made me curious, but the film gives relatively little context for some of these figures.
The same applies to Circe and her ability to transform humans into animals. If you already know the mythology, you can fill in a lot of the gaps yourself. But the movie occasionally seems to assume that familiarity instead of providing enough background within the film itself.
I would have liked more of that.
The underworld also looked different from what I had imagined.
The journey to Hades has always felt much stranger and more otherworldly in my head, and the film’s interpretation felt almost too grounded for me.
The same applies to parts of Odysseus’ path toward Calypso. I know different adaptations and retellings handle these sections differently, but there were moments where I personally would have chosen another approach.
That may also be connected to Nolan’s obsession with doing as much as possible practically.
Usually I love that philosophy.
And visually, the result here is remarkable.
But Greek mythology is one of those rare settings where I actually think a little more CGI can be useful. Sometimes something is supposed to feel impossible. Hades does not necessarily need to look like somewhere a camera crew could physically stand.
That said, these are mostly things I wanted more of rather than things I actively disliked.
And that distinction matters.
I wanted more context because the world interested me.
I wanted more mythology because the film made me want to spend longer inside it.
I wanted to understand certain characters because they felt worth understanding.
That is hardly a devastating criticism.
The Odyssey is visually stunning, beautifully acted, wonderfully scored, and remarkably respectful toward the mythology it adapts.
It is also refreshing to see Christopher Nolan step away from the narrative machinery he is famous for and simply trust an ancient story to carry a gigantic modern production.
And it works.