FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

The Mule

2018 2.5/51 review

Original review

2.5/5

The Mule is one of those films that I enjoyed watching but struggled to remember particularly well afterwards.

And that is a little frustrating because there is actually quite a lot to appreciate.

The premise is interesting, Clint Eastwood's central character has a distinctive personality, and the story offers a surprisingly unusual perspective on crime.

I also think the film deserves a little more appreciation than it sometimes receives.

But despite those qualities, it never quite became something memorable enough for me to rate it particularly highly.

What initially makes The Mule so interesting is the protagonist.

Earl Stone is not the kind of character you would normally expect to find at the center of a drug trafficking story.

He is an elderly man whose life has become increasingly complicated, and who suddenly discovers an opportunity to make money through something extraordinarily dangerous.

That contrast is fascinating.

Crime thrillers often focus on young, ambitious characters entering dangerous criminal organizations or experienced professionals who already understand the world they operate in.

The Mule takes a different approach.

Earl is not presented as some brilliant criminal mastermind.

He is someone whose age, personality, and ordinary appearance allow him to exist in circumstances where he might otherwise seem completely out of place.

And that makes the story entertaining.

Clint Eastwood is excellent at portraying this particular kind of character.

There is a certain stubbornness to Earl.

He has his own opinions.

His own habits.

And a way of approaching situations that can be simultaneously frustrating and charming.

He does not always seem particularly interested in changing himself to satisfy the expectations of others.

And that gives him an interesting personality.

I enjoyed watching him.

There is also something compelling about how the film explores the consequences of the life Earl has already lived.

His involvement in crime is not simply an isolated adventure.

It exists alongside personal relationships, regrets, and the realization that certain mistakes cannot easily be undone.

That gives the story a more human foundation.

The film is not solely concerned with whether Earl will successfully complete another dangerous journey.

It also explores what his decisions reveal about the person he has become.

And I appreciate that.

There are some interesting themes about aging, responsibility, family, and the difference between financial success and genuine personal fulfillment.

Those ideas give the movie more substance than a conventional crime story might otherwise possess.

And Clint Eastwood's presence makes them reasonably effective.

The film also creates suspense through the unusual nature of Earl's situation.

He is operating in a dangerous world that does not seem naturally suited to someone like him.

And that makes the possibility of everything going wrong constantly interesting.

I enjoyed that part of the story.

The problem is that the movie never left a particularly strong impression on me.

It is entertaining while it lasts.

The character is good.

The premise is interesting.

And the film has enough tension to keep the experience engaging.

But afterwards, very little remained.

There are movies that immediately make me want to discuss their characters, revisit certain scenes, or think about the questions they raise.

The Mule never quite achieved that.

And I find that disappointing because its underlying ideas are actually quite worthwhile.

Perhaps the problem is that the film never develops its premise into something especially distinctive beyond Earl's unusual position within the criminal world.

I appreciate the character study, but it does not become emotionally powerful enough to stay with me.

And while the criminal storyline is entertaining, it rarely reaches the intensity or narrative complexity of my favorite thrillers.

The result is a film that sits somewhere between a good character drama and a reasonably exciting crime movie without becoming exceptional in either category.

But I also do not want to be overly negative.

There is something admirable about making a movie centered on an older, imperfect protagonist whose personality is far removed from the usual Hollywood action hero.

The film has a certain maturity and restraint that I appreciate.

And Eastwood brings enough authenticity to the character to make the journey enjoyable.

That is why I think The Mule might actually be a little underrated.

It has interesting qualities that are easy to overlook if you approach it expecting a conventional thriller.

It is quieter, more character focused, and more interested in the personal consequences of Earl's decisions than in spectacular criminal action.

Those are good things.

They simply did not come together into a film that left a lasting impression on me.

Two and a half stars.

An entertaining and somewhat underrated crime drama with an interesting premise and a wonderfully distinctive Clint Eastwood character.

A film I enjoyed more while watching than I remembered afterwards.

And sometimes that is the difference between something good and something truly memorable.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗