Original review
The Highwaymen is a particularly frustrating movie because almost everything about its premise sounds like something I should enjoy.
A historical crime story about the pursuit of Bonnie and Clyde.
Kevin Costner and Woody Harrelson in the leading roles.
A fascinating period of American history.
And the opportunity to explore one of the country's most notorious criminal cases from a perspective that is considerably less romanticized than usual.
That is a genuinely strong foundation.
Unfortunately, the film takes so incredibly long to tell its story that much of my initial interest gradually disappeared.
And that is a shame.
The cast is easily one of the strongest elements.
Kevin Costner brings exactly the kind of restrained, experienced presence that works for a character like Frank Hamer.
He feels like someone who has already seen enough violence and human cruelty to approach the entire situation with a different perspective from the people surrounding him.
There is little romanticism in his attitude toward the criminals he is pursuing.
He understands the consequences of their actions, and that gives the story a certain seriousness.
Woody Harrelson is equally enjoyable as Maney Gault.
His personality creates a good contrast with Costner's more reserved character, and the dynamic between the two men is one of the few things that consistently kept me interested.
Both actors are extremely capable, and there is a natural chemistry between them that makes even ordinary conversations reasonably entertaining.
The historical setting is also very appealing.
I enjoy films that take the time to recreate a particular period, especially when the story is based on real people and events.
The cars, clothes, environments, and general atmosphere help establish a world that feels far removed from modern criminal investigations.
There is something fascinating about watching experienced lawmen pursue dangerous criminals with the limited resources and communication technology of the 1930s.
The film also has an interesting perspective on Bonnie and Clyde.
Instead of presenting them primarily as rebellious folk heroes, it focuses on the people tasked with ending their violent crime spree.
That approach provides an opportunity to examine the difference between the mythology surrounding criminals and the much uglier reality of their actions.
I appreciate that idea.
The problem is simply the execution.
The pacing is painfully slow.
There is a difference between deliberately allowing a historical story to develop and stretching the narrative until the audience begins losing interest.
For me, The Highwaymen regularly crosses that line.
Far too many scenes feel longer than they need to be.
Conversations continue without adding much.
The investigation moves forward, but rarely with enough momentum to make the progress exciting.
And eventually, the film begins feeling much longer than its actual runtime.
That is particularly frustrating because the story itself is interesting.
I wanted to know more about the characters.
I wanted to follow the investigation.
And I wanted to see how this particular interpretation of the historical events would unfold.
But the movie makes that experience unnecessarily exhausting.
A good historical drama does not need constant action or rapid editing.
Some of my favorite films are relatively quiet and patient.
But those films usually compensate with exceptional character development, psychological tension, or a narrative that constantly gives you something meaningful to think about.
Here, the slowness never felt sufficiently rewarding.
Instead of becoming more immersed in the investigation, I gradually became more aware of how little seemed to be happening.
And that is one of the worst things a film can do when it already has a fascinating story and such talented actors at its disposal.
The Highwaymen is certainly not without merit.
The historical premise is strong, the performances are convincing, and the production captures its period well.
But those qualities cannot completely compensate for storytelling that feels so unnecessarily drawn out.
Two stars.
A fascinating historical crime story with an excellent cast, unfortunately buried underneath pacing that makes an already lengthy investigation feel almost endless.
Sometimes a great cast and an interesting true story still need a director willing to get to the point.