FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

Spider-Man: Homecoming

2017 3/51 review

Original review

3/5

Spider-Man: Homecoming is a perfectly enjoyable superhero movie.

And somehow, that is also my biggest problem with it.

Because Spider-Man has always been a character capable of considerably more than simply providing two hours of entertaining Marvel action.

There is something special about Peter Parker.

He is not supposed to be the most powerful person in the room.

He is not supposed to have everything figured out.

He is young, inexperienced, occasionally overwhelmed, and constantly trying to balance a normal life with responsibilities that most people could barely imagine.

That is what makes him such an interesting superhero.

And Homecoming definitely understands parts of that.

Tom Holland brings a youthful energy to Peter Parker that fits this interpretation of the character very well.

His excitement, insecurity, and desire to prove himself make him believable as someone who is still learning what it actually means to be Spider-Man.

There is something charming about watching a superhero who is not yet completely comfortable being one.

He makes mistakes.

He gets carried away.

He wants recognition.

And he occasionally seems more interested in becoming an Avenger than in understanding why being a hero matters in the first place.

That provides a good foundation for character development.

I also appreciate that the film moves away from simply retelling the origin story that almost everyone already knows.

We do not need to watch Uncle Ben die for the third time to understand who Peter Parker is.

Instead, the movie focuses on a different stage of his development, which is a sensible decision.

The problem is that the overall experience never quite reaches the level I associate with the best Spider-Man films.

When I compare Homecoming to the earlier adaptations, something feels missing.

Those movies had a particular emotional weight, a distinctive atmosphere, and a stronger sense that Peter's personal life and his responsibilities as Spider-Man were constantly pulling him in different directions.

Homecoming is more playful.

More integrated into the wider Marvel universe.

And often more interested in being entertaining than emotionally profound.

There is nothing inherently wrong with that approach.

In fact, it makes the movie very easy to watch.

The humor works, the action is enjoyable, and the characters have enough personality to keep the story moving.

But being enjoyable is not necessarily the same as being memorable.

And when I compare it to the newer Spider-Man films, the difference becomes even more noticeable.

The later movies develop Peter considerably further, confront him with much more difficult emotional consequences, and give his relationships a weight that makes his decisions feel genuinely important.

Homecoming is still establishing that foundation.

And while I understand why that is necessary, it makes the movie feel relatively lightweight in retrospect.

There are good ideas here about responsibility, identity, and learning that being a hero has very little to do with having impressive technology or being recognized by powerful people.

Those themes fit Spider-Man perfectly.

I simply do not think the film explores them with enough depth to become something exceptional.

It feels like a solid introduction to a new version of Peter Parker rather than a definitive Spider-Man story.

And perhaps that is exactly what it was intended to be.

Not every installment in a franchise needs to become its greatest achievement.

Sometimes a movie simply needs to establish its characters, create an entertaining adventure, and prepare the ground for more ambitious stories.

Homecoming accomplishes that.

It is charming, funny, competently made, and has a likable protagonist.

But when I think about the Spider-Man films that genuinely stayed with me, this one rarely comes to mind first.

The older movies have their own particular magic.

The newer ones eventually develop much stronger emotional stakes.

And Homecoming sits somewhere in the middle, doing a lot of things reasonably well without ever completely standing out.

Three stars.

A charming and entertaining introduction to Tom Holland's Spider-Man, but one that struggles to match either the emotional identity of the earlier films or the stronger character development of the later installments.

Good Spider-Man.

Just not great Spider-Man.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗