FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

Sinners

2025 1/51 review

Original review

1/5

I can give this film credit for one thing: it looks great. The cinematography is strong, the atmosphere is there, and visually it clearly knows what kind of movie it wants to be. Unfortunately, that was pretty much the only part that worked for me.

The biggest problem is that the film feels way too long for how little it actually manages to do with its story. It spends what feels like half its runtime introducing characters, but somehow not even in a satisfying or complete way. Instead of building real investment, it just keeps circling around people and ideas without ever making me care enough about them. By the time the plot is finally supposed to kick into gear, I was already more frustrated than engaged.

And once the story does fully reveal itself, it honestly just becomes more confusing rather than more compelling. The whole mix of vampires, racism, revenge, and all these half-developed side elements never really came together for me in a way that felt coherent. Characters and ideas are introduced as if they are going to matter a lot, and then the film either drops them entirely or barely does anything meaningful with them. The Indigenous vampire hunters are probably the clearest example of that: they show up with the kind of presence that makes you think they are going to play an important role, and then it basically leads nowhere. That kind of storytelling just makes the whole movie feel messy.

The film also leans so heavily into sexualization that, for me, it stopped adding atmosphere and just started making the whole thing feel even more unfocused. Instead of deepening the tension or the characters, it often felt like one more ingredient thrown into an already overcrowded movie. And that is really the core issue here: this film keeps throwing things at the screen and expecting that intensity alone will hold it together.

Then the ending completely lost me. The final battle felt so exaggerated and unrealistic that any remaining tension was gone. Instead of feeling earned or cathartic, it just came across as blunt, chaotic, and emotionally hollow. At that point I was no longer invested in what was happening — I was just waiting for it to end.

What frustrates me most is that there is clearly talent behind it. You can see it in the visuals. You can feel that it wants to be bold, provocative, and memorable. But for me, it confused “having a lot going on” with actually telling a strong story. A film can be violent, sexual, political, weird, and genre-heavy all at once — but only if it has the narrative control to carry all of that. This didn’t.

So yes, it looks good. But beyond that, I found it overlong, dramatically messy, tonally all over the place, and ultimately not nearly as smart or gripping as it seemed to think it was.

One star for the cinematography. Everything else just never came together for me.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗