FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

One Hundred and One Dalmatians

1961 3.5/51 review

Original review

3.5/5

There are movies that you appreciate with your mind.

And then there are movies that a part of your heart would happily give five stars simply because of what they represent.

One Hundred and One Dalmatians is somewhere between those two experiences for me.

Because this is an absolute Disney classic.

The animation is wonderful.

The music is fantastic.

And the entire movie has a particular kind of charm that makes it incredibly easy to love.

But as much as I appreciate it, I also think it is important to evaluate a film in relation to everything else I have watched.

And that is why I am giving it three and a half stars.

Even though part of me would love to rate it higher.

What I particularly appreciate about One Hundred and One Dalmatians is its visual identity.

There is something incredibly beautiful about traditional hand drawn animation.

Not necessarily because every individual image needs to be technically perfect.

But because the artistic personality is visible in almost every frame.

The lines.

The movements.

The backgrounds.

And the way the characters are designed to communicate emotions through relatively simple expressions.

Everything has a distinctive quality that is difficult to reproduce through more modern techniques.

And the film embraces that beautifully.

The animation style has a wonderful sense of character.

It is expressive without becoming excessively complicated.

The environments feel like illustrations brought to life.

And the dogs themselves have an enormous amount of personality despite their relatively simple visual designs.

I love that.

The film was also an important step in the development of Disney animation, using xerographic techniques to transfer drawings into the animation process.

That contributed to its characteristic sketchlike outlines.

And I think those outlines are part of what makes the movie so visually recognizable.

It has a different feeling from some of the earlier Disney classics.

A little more graphic.

A little more modern.

And wonderfully suited to the urban environments and character designs.

The London setting is another great quality.

There is something charming about the streets, houses, parks, and general atmosphere of the city.

The movie creates a comfortable world that feels familiar while still allowing the animals to experience their own extraordinary adventures within it.

And I particularly enjoy the way the story is told through the perspective of the dogs.

Pongo and Perdita are wonderful central characters.

Their personalities are immediately likable, and the film establishes their relationships with the human characters in a way that feels warm and natural.

The entire opening has a lovely sense of humor.

There is something amusing about watching the dogs become involved in the romantic lives of their owners.

And that playful perspective gives the story a distinctive personality.

Then there is Cruella de Vil.

An absolutely iconic Disney villain.

Her exaggerated appearance, personality, and behavior make her immediately recognizable.

She is theatrical, selfish, and almost impossibly unpleasant.

But she is also a wonderfully entertaining character.

There is something extraordinary about how effectively a villain can be established through visual design and personality alone.

And Cruella is a perfect example.

The music contributes enormously to that impression.

The song about Cruella de Vil is unforgettable.

It fits the character perfectly and has exactly the kind of distinctive musical identity that makes classic Disney films so memorable.

And the broader soundtrack contributes beautifully to the atmosphere.

I really appreciate that.

Music has always been one of Disney's greatest strengths.

A familiar melody can immediately bring back the feeling of a particular film.

And One Hundred and One Dalmatians certainly has that quality.

The story itself is charming and entertaining.

There is a clear emotional objective, a recognizable villain, and plenty of opportunities for adventure and suspense.

The film also has an appealing sense of community.

Different animals contribute to the effort to protect the puppies, and that cooperation gives the story a warm emotional foundation.

There is something wonderful about an animated adventure that creates such a strong sense of affection for its characters.

And this movie absolutely achieves that.

But when I compare it with my favorite animated films, I also notice the differences.

Some of the greatest animated movies I have watched combine their entertainment value with extraordinarily sophisticated storytelling, emotional development, and philosophical depth.

Films like Ratatouille, WALL-E, and Cars manage to entertain me while also exploring ideas that remain meaningful long after the movie ends.

One Hundred and One Dalmatians does not have quite the same impact on me.

Its story is relatively straightforward.

The characters are charming, but the emotional development is less complex.

And while the adventure is enjoyable, it does not reach the same level of narrative sophistication as my absolute favorites.

That is not an insult.

It is simply an important distinction.

A film can be historically significant, beautifully animated, and incredibly charming without automatically deserving the highest possible rating.

And I think maintaining that distinction makes the ratings more meaningful.

If every beloved childhood classic received five stars simply because it inspires affection, those stars would eventually stop communicating how the films actually compare.

That is why I want to be consistent.

I can love the atmosphere.

I can appreciate the music.

I can admire the animation.

And I can recognize the film's place in Disney history.

But I can also acknowledge that other animated movies have impressed me more deeply.

Three and a half stars.

A beautiful, charming, and wonderfully recognizable Disney classic with fantastic traditional animation, memorable music, and an iconic villain.

My heart would happily give it more.

But my actual evaluation has to account for the extraordinary animated films I have seen since.

And that does not make One Hundred and One Dalmatians any less special.

Some movies deserve to be remembered with enormous affection, even when they are not quite among your highest rated favorites.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗