Original review
Insidious: Out of the Further is a genuinely good horror movie and, most importantly, I simply had a lot of fun watching it.
It knows how to create tension, it has enough genuinely creepy moments to keep the atmosphere alive, and it still feels recognizably like an Insidious film without just repeating everything the franchise has already done. The whole idea surrounding Gemma and her connection to the Further gives the movie enough of its own identity to make this new chapter feel worthwhile.
That being said, there is one decision I could not stop thinking about for basically the entire movie:
WHY ARE YOU STILL LIVING IN THAT HOUSE?
At some point, self-preservation has to enter the conversation.
Gemma is living in the same house connected to some of the most traumatic and supernatural experiences of her life, increasingly obvious paranormal things are happening around her, and somehow leaving still seems to be treated like an unreasonable suggestion.
Meanwhile, Nick — her cop boyfriend — almost immediately has the much more sensible instinct that maybe continuing to live in the horrifying childhood home is not the greatest idea. Even Maya seems to have a better sense of danger than her mother at times.
Honestly, Nick might be the smartest person in the entire movie purely because his reaction is basically what any normal human being would do:
This place is clearly haunted. Maybe we should not live here.
Thank you, Nick.
The rest of the movie still works surprisingly well despite that horror-movie logic. The atmosphere is strong, the scares are effective, and the Further remains such a great concept because it allows the franchise to create horror that feels slightly disconnected from normal reality. You never quite know what rules still apply once the movie crosses into that space, which gives even familiar horror situations an uncomfortable edge.
I also liked that the film introduces a new family instead of desperately dragging the same characters through another identical haunting. Gemma and Maya give the story a different emotional center, while bringing Elise Rainier back maintains enough connection to the older films that it still feels like part of the same universe.
It is not an exceptional horror film, though. There are still plenty of genre conventions, and some character decisions exist mostly because otherwise the sensible solution would end the movie after twenty minutes.
But sometimes that is fine.
I was entertained, I was tense, and there were enough effective horror moments that I walked out of the cinema satisfied. That is already more than a lot of modern franchise horror manages.
3.5 stars feels right: a genuinely enjoyable addition to the series with a fun new concept and solid scares.
I just spent approximately half the runtime mentally screaming at Gemma to call a real-estate agent.
If your cop boyfriend and your ten-year-old daughter both have better paranormal survival instincts than you, maybe it is time to reconsider the mortgage.