FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny

2023 2/51 review

Original review

2/5

There is something strangely bittersweet about watching Indiana Jones return for another adventure.

On one hand, it is wonderful to see Harrison Ford step back into one of the most iconic roles in cinema history.

On the other hand, a film like Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny immediately reminds me just how difficult it is to recreate the magic of something that belongs so strongly to another era of filmmaking.

And unfortunately, this movie never quite manages to do that.

I have a lot of affection for the original Indiana Jones films.

They represent a particular kind of adventure cinema that is incredibly difficult to replicate.

There is excitement, mystery, humor, danger, and an almost childlike fascination with discovering something extraordinary.

The stories are often ridiculous when you think about them too carefully, but that never really matters.

They are made with so much personality and confidence that you simply enjoy the adventure.

That is what makes the classics special.

And it is exactly what I missed here.

To be fair, Dial of Destiny is not a completely unsuccessful attempt to revive the franchise.

There are moments where the old feeling returns.

The familiar music, Harrison Ford's presence, the archaeological mysteries, and the recognizable elements of an Indiana Jones adventure occasionally create a genuinely pleasant sense of nostalgia.

For a few moments, you remember why you loved these movies in the first place.

And I appreciated that.

It is nice to revisit a character who has accompanied generations of moviegoers.

There is also something interesting about seeing an older Indiana Jones.

The character is no longer the seemingly unstoppable adventurer from the original films.

Time has passed.

The world has changed.

And the man who once seemed perfectly suited to exploring ancient mysteries now finds himself navigating an era that does not always seem to have much room for someone like him.

That is a potentially compelling idea.

A film about an aging adventurer coming to terms with his own history could have been genuinely moving.

And Harrison Ford certainly has the ability to make that kind of story work.

Unfortunately, the actual movie feels much more interested in creating another enormous adventure than in fully exploring what makes this particular stage of Indiana Jones's life meaningful.

The action is there.

The familiar formula is there.

The mysterious artifact is there.

But the charm that once made everything feel so effortless is only occasionally present.

And that is the problem with trying to revive a beloved franchise.

You can reproduce its recognizable ingredients without necessarily reproducing the feeling those ingredients once created.

The original films had a wonderful balance between practical adventure, humor, suspense, and the personalities of their characters.

They felt exciting without constantly needing to become bigger.

The action had a particular rhythm.

The discoveries felt mysterious.

And the characters had an almost timeless appeal.

Dial of Destiny sometimes feels like it is trying so hard to remind the audience of those qualities that it forgets to create enough of its own.

The result is a movie that is perfectly watchable but rarely particularly memorable.

I did enjoy seeing Indiana Jones again.

And I would be lying if I said that certain moments did not make me nostalgic.

But nostalgia alone cannot turn an average adventure film into a great one.

Especially when it constantly invites comparisons with movies that are considerably more entertaining.

I also think that there is a difference between giving a beloved character one final adventure and truly understanding why people fell in love with that character in the first place.

The old Indiana Jones movies were never special simply because Harrison Ford wore a hat and carried a whip.

They were special because everything surrounding those recognizable elements worked together beautifully.

The stories.

The characters.

The humor.

The adventure.

The atmosphere.

That combination is much harder to recreate than any individual visual reference.

And despite its best efforts, Dial of Destiny never really gets there.

Two stars.

A reasonably entertaining attempt to bring an iconic adventure franchise back to life, with a few genuinely nostalgic moments and the undeniable pleasure of seeing Harrison Ford return.

But sometimes the original magic simply belongs to the original films.

And nothing really compares to the old Indiana Jones adventures.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗