FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

Heretic

2024 2.5/51 review

Original review

2.5/5

Heretic was entertaining enough while I was watching it, but by the end it also left me with the feeling that there just was not that much depth to it. It is one of those films that works well enough on a surface level to keep you engaged, but once it is over, there is not a lot beneath that initial entertainment value that really sticks. I never felt completely bored, but I also never felt like the film gave me much more than a decent setup and a few effective moments.

That is probably my biggest issue with it: it feels like it should have more weight than it actually does. A film like this depends a lot on atmosphere, psychological tension, and the sense that there is something deeper going on underneath the horror. But for me, Heretic never fully reached that level. It gestures toward complexity more than it truly delivers it, and because of that, the whole thing ends up feeling a little thinner than it wants to be.

A lot of the attention naturally goes to Hugh Grant, and I can definitely see why. He has clearly been trying out more varied roles lately, which I do respect, and it is always more interesting when actors are willing to step outside the lane people know them for. But in this case, I could not shake the feeling that this genre just does not suit him nearly as well as the kinds of roles that originally made him so likable. For me, he was always at his best in rom-coms, where his charm, timing, and natural screen presence fit perfectly. That is the version of Hugh Grant I loved, and compared to that, this kind of horror-leaning role just does not feel like the best use of what makes him work.

That does not necessarily mean he is bad here. It is more that the overall fit feels off to me. The performance never fully convinced me in the way it probably needed to for the film to become something stronger. In a story that relies so much on discomfort, tension, and a certain kind of menace, the central performance has to feel completely locked in. Here, I mostly found it interesting in theory more than truly effective in practice.

The film is still watchable, though, and I do not think it is a total misfire. There is enough there to make it an okay viewing experience, and I can understand why some people might enjoy it more than I did. But for me, it stayed too much in that middle zone: not bad enough to strongly dislike, not strong enough to really admire. It is the kind of film that passes the time reasonably well, but never fully justifies itself beyond that.

So 2.5 stars feels right. Fairly entertaining, occasionally effective, but ultimately too lacking in depth to leave much of an impact — and not really the kind of role that plays to Hugh Grant’s strongest qualities.

Watchable enough, but too shallow to really linger, and a reminder that Hugh Grant still fits rom-coms better than horror.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗