Original review
Bad Times at the El Royale is a film that worked much better for me the first time than it did on a rewatch.
And I think a huge part of that comes down to atmosphere.
The setting is fantastic.
The hotel has this strange, mysterious, slightly artificial feeling that immediately makes you curious about everyone inside it.
There is tension in the architecture itself.
You always feel like something is hidden behind the walls, inside the rooms, or underneath what people are saying.
That atmosphere carried a lot of the film for me.
The first time around, the mystery was enough to make everything feel exciting.
The second time, once I already knew where the story was going, a lot of that magic disappeared.
Without the mystery doing as much work, the story itself suddenly felt much stranger and less convincing.
Some character decisions feel odd.
Some story elements feel more interesting in theory than in execution.
And once the surprise is gone, the structure becomes easier to see.
That does not mean the film becomes bad.
The performances are still strong, the setting still works, and there is enough tension to make it entertaining.
But for me, this is one of those films where the first viewing is clearly the best one.
A stylish and atmospheric mystery that loses a lot of its power once you already know what is hiding inside the hotel.