FRAME.The cinematic edition · 2.2
← Back to the collectionFRAME. / THE REVIEW FILES
The personal collection

Avatar: Fire and Ash

2025 3/51 review

Original review

3/5

Avatar: Fire and Ash is still visually impressive, still technically incredible, and still very easy to admire as a piece of filmmaking.

But this time, I felt like I had already seen most of it before.

After The Way of Water introduced a genuinely different environment and gave Pandora a fresh visual identity, I expected the next film to push the world forward again in the same way. Instead, Fire and Ash often feels far too similar to what came directly before it.

The spectacle is still there. The world still looks incredible. The animation is still among the best you can find in modern cinema.

But the sense of discovery is weaker.

A lot of the structure, emotional beats, and overall feeling reminded me so strongly of The Way of Water that the film started to feel less like the next chapter and more like another variation of the same one.

And when a franchise is built around such an enormous and imaginative universe, repetition becomes especially frustrating.

Pandora should feel almost limitless. There should always be another culture, another landscape, another conflict, another way of seeing this world. So when a sequel feels this familiar, it becomes difficult not to think about all the possibilities that could have been explored instead.

The story also remains relatively superficial. There are still interesting themes and emotional ideas underneath everything, but once again, they never feel as developed as the world around them.

That does not make Fire and Ash bad.

It is still entertaining, visually spectacular, and very polished. But the third time around, technical brilliance alone is no longer enough to create the same sense of wonder.

For me, 3 stars feels right.

There is still a lot to admire here, but far less to discover.

Another beautiful trip to Pandora — unfortunately, this time it feels a little too much like we never really left the previous one.

Read this review on Letterboxd ↗